The purpose of this site is to provide information on the Eastern New Mexico Water Utility Authority (ENMWUA) Project to build a seventy (70) mile water pipeline from Clovis, New Mexico to Ute Lake in Quay County, New Mexico near Logan. In the summer of 2022 ENMWUA estimated the cost of completing the pipeline project would be approximately $800 million dollars [1]
It is the author’s position that as a result of the severe drought being experienced in the southwest ENMWUA is about to waste hundreds of millions of dollars building a pipeline to Ute Lake which is not a sustainable water resource. Instead ENMWUA should be focusing its efforts on purchasing ground water rights in Eastern New Mexico. In 2010 93% of all water pumped from the aquifer in Curry and Roosevelt counties was for irrigated agriculture, only 3% was for public consumption [2]. Reducing the percentage of water pumped for irrigation by purchasing water rights would insure Curry and Roosevelt County an ample public water supply indefinitely.
Warren Frost
The headwaters of the Canadian River are approximately two (2) miles north of the New Mexico border in Las Animas County, Colorado. In New Mexico the Canadian River passes west of Raton and flows southeastward to its first dam which is Conchas Lake in San Miguel County. It then flows east into Quay County, New Mexico 45 miles where it is again dammed to form Ute Lake. From Ute Dam the Canadian River flows into the Texas Panhandle a distance of 65 river miles to Sanford Dam which creates Lake Meredith in Hutchinson County near Borger, Texas. From Lake Meredith the Canadian River travels into Oklahoma and ultimately flows into the Arkansas River {3].
Of the three (3) lakes in Eastern New Mexico and the Texas Panhandle, both Conchas Lake and Lake Meredith supply water to third parties. Ute Lake does not. To get an idea of Ute Lake’s viability in providing water to ENMWUA as part of its pipeline project, one can compare the effect the drought has had since 2000 on the water projects at Conchas Lake and Lake Meredith.
Lake Meredith provides water to the Canadian River Municipal Water Authority (CRWMA). CRWMA provides municipal drinking water for eleven communities in the Texas Panhandle including Amarillo and Lubbock, with a total population over a half million people [5]. The Lake Meredith watershed is 16,048 square miles.
From the early 1970’s through 2001, Lake Meredith provided a majority of the water CRMWA suppled to its member cities. Beginning in the 1999 the inflow of water to Lake Meredith decreased substantially [6]. Lake Meredith provide no water for CRWMA in 2012 or 2013 and for the last 10 years Lake Meredith provided less than 20% of CRWMA’s water requirements because of drought conditions. Over 80% of its water comes from ground water well fields [7].
In the mid 1990’s CRMWA began to develop groundwater sources to supplement its surface water supply from Lake Meredith. CRMWA initially acquired 42,594 acres of ground water rights in Roberts County, installed well fields, and transmission facilities to deliver water into its existing aquifer system and to its member cities. As Lake Meredith’s level continued to decline through the 1990’s and 2000’s and the water supply availability from the lake declined, CRMWA in several increments acquired additional groundwater rights and expanded its ground water production and delivery system. As of September 30, 2009, CRMWA had acquired a total of 260,000 acres of water rights. CRMWA is now one of the largest water rights owners in Texas owning over 442,800 acres of ground water rights, enough to secure the supply of water to its member cities though the year 2140. CRMWA has spent approximately $286,730,000 to acquire these groundwater rights and to develop the distribution system to its member cities [8].
The Arch Hurley Conservancy District (AHCD) is an irrigation district primarily in Quay County, New Mexico which draws water from Conchas Lake to irrigate up to 42,000 acres. AHCD irrigated its first acreage in 1947. Every year between 1947 and 2001 the AHCD provided irrigation water to the conservancy district. During that 54 year period the least amount of water released from Conchas Lake was 20,780 acre feet in 1976 {4}.
Between 2001 and 2022 there have been nine (9) years when AHCD provided no water to the conservancy district including the last three (3) years 2020 thru 2022. The Conchas Lake watershed is 7409 square miles.
Ute Dam and Reservoir was completed in 1963 with an initial storage capacity of 109,600 acre feet of water. In 1984 New Mexico completed the enlargement of Ute Reservoir which increased its capacity to 272,800 acre feet. With the exception of very limited use of golf course irrigation, diversions have yet to occur from Ute Lake Reservoir. Annual decline in lake levels are associated with drought conditions, seepage through the dam, and evaporation.
A review of the year-end total acre foot storage in Ute Reservoir during the 16 year period between January 1, 2008 and January 1, 2023 demonstrate that in 11 of those 16 years the January 1st lake levels were lower than they have been 12 months previously. On January 1, 2023 the total storage at Ute Lake stood at 128,000 acre feet the lowest lake level since 2008 with the exception of January 1, 2013 when the lake storage was 119,000 acre feet [9]. These measurements demonstrate substantial reductions in lake storage for no other reason than seepage and evaporation. The Ute Lake watershed is 3,852 square miles
The basis for the ENMWUA pipeline project is the 1994 study completed by John Whipple of the New Mexico Interstate Stream Commission. Mr. Whipple studied the Canadian River flow from 1943 through 1993 and determined that the lake would generate between 18,000 and 22,500 acre feet of water per year [10]. Based upon that study the New Mexico Interstate Stream Commission entered into the Ute Reservoir Water Contract with Eastern New Mexico communities which called for the ultimate removal of 24,000 acre feet of water annually from Ute Lake Reservoir [11]. Of that amount 16,400 acre feet are reserved for ENMWUA and its communities [12]. The remainder is reserved to Quay County entities that are not part of the pipeline project.
ENMWUA has done substantial work building connecting pipelines between Clovis, Texico, Portales, and Cannon Air Force Base. This pipeline infrastructure is being completed and is not part of the $800 million projected cost to complete the pipeline to Ute Lake.
Of the 3 lakes, Conchas, Ute and Meredith, Ute has by far the smallest watershed at 3,852 square miles. 3,557 square miles less than Conchas Lake and 12,196 square miles less that Lake Meredith. Both Conchas and Meredith have been affected dramatically by drought conditions to the point of not being able to accomplish their intended purpose of supplying water to AHCD and CRMWA. And yet ENMWUA intends to spend $800 million dollars building a pipeline to Ute Lake with the smallest watershed on the Canadian River.
CRMWA spent $287 million for ground water rights and infrastructure to supply over 500,000 people in the Texas Panhandle with water until 2140. ENMWUA is planning to spend $800 million to supply the 67,000 Curry and Roosevelt County citizens with a pipeline to Ute Lake that will not solve their water problems. If CRMWA can solve the water problem of over 500,000 people by $287 million with ground water, surely ENMWUA can solve the water issues facing the 67,000 people in Curry and Roosevelt counties for the same price. Even if it cost $574 million, twice as much, ENMWUA would still be saving $225 million dollars. All of the pipeline construction between Clovis, Texico, Portales, and Cannon Airforce Base that has been completed can easily be used to supply groundwater. It is not too late to change course.
It is time that local, state, and federal officials recognize that the goal is solving Curry and Roosevelt’s water problems, not building a pipeline.
Utepipeline.com
Copyright © 2024 Utepipeline.com - All Rights Reserved.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.